The £50,000 Gym Membership
Why your retirement budget might be costing you years of freedom.
I recently noticed an unused gym membership among a list of everyday household direct debits. It was costing £100 a month.
Most people would see that as a £100 decision. I saw it differently. Because continuing to spend that £100 a month after I finish work might mean I need around another £50,000 in retirement savings to fund it.
The same could be true of the second car that rarely leaves the driveway. The storage unit you haven’t visited in years. The subscriptions you stopped noticing long ago.
Not because any of these things is necessarily expensive in isolation. Because every recurring expense quietly increases the amount of money you need to sustain your lifestyle.
A £100 monthly direct debit is £1,200 a year. If you expect to keep paying it throughout retirement—and want that spending to rise with inflation—you may need tens of thousands of pounds more to support it.
The precise figure will depend on tax, investment returns, inflation and how long your retirement lasts. But once you allow for those uncertainties and the possibility of spending 30 years or more in retirement, £50,000 is far from an unreasonable illustration.
Of course, if you use the gym three times a week, feel fitter, sleep better and enjoy going, it may be excellent value.
But if you haven’t been for six months, that is a very expensive habit.
Sometimes the most expensive costs are the ones we no longer notice.
The Retirement Target Nobody Questions
Most people think retirement planning is about building the largest pension they can.
They ask:
How much have I saved?
What return am I earning?
Should I increase my contributions?
When can I afford to retire?
Those are sensible questions. But they all focus on one side of the equation.
The other side is what your retirement will actually cost.
Most retirement plans begin by asking how much money you will need. Far fewer begin by asking what kind of life that money is supposed to buy.
That matters because your expected spending helps determine the amount you need to accumulate. The higher the spending, the larger the target. The larger the target, the longer you may need to work.
And sometimes that target includes expenditure that adds very little to your life.
Imagine someone preparing a retirement budget that includes:
a gym membership they rarely use;
several streaming services;
a premium mobile contract;
a storage unit full of things they have forgotten about;
an expensive second car they barely drive;
None of these costs appears especially dramatic on its own.
But together they might amount to £500 a month—or £6,000 a year.
Depending on the assumptions used, supporting that spending throughout retirement could require £200,000 or more in additional savings. It is not a universal calculation, but it demonstrates the scale of the issue.
So the person keeps working towards the higher figure. They save more, worry more and might even delay retirement by two or three years.
All to preserve spending they do not especially value.
Tomorrow’s freedom is being traded for spending that no longer matters.
Spend less—or spend better?
This is not an argument for cutting everything enjoyable from your life.
A good meal, a holiday, a golf membership, a theatre subscription or a car you genuinely love may be worth every penny.
The point is not to spend as little as possible. It is to spend deliberately.
A £5,000 holiday that gives you memories for years may offer far greater value than £1,200 spent on a gym you never visit. A restaurant you love may be worth more to you than three forgotten subscriptions.
Value for money is personal. Nobody else can decide whether a particular expense deserves a place in your life.
The useful question is not simply:
“Can I afford this?”
It is:
“Is this worth what it is costing my future?”
That question applies to large expenses, but it may be even more valuable when applied to the smaller ones. Major purchases attract attention. Direct debits disappear quietly in the background.
Build the budget for the life ahead
When people prepare a retirement budget, they often begin by looking backwards.
They open their banking app, export twelve months of transactions and assume that the future should cost roughly the same as the present.
But retirement is not simply a continuation of your working life without the salary. Your routines, priorities and use of time may all change.
Some current costs will disappear. Others will increase. You may want to travel more, help your family or devote money to interests that working life left little time for.
The better question is not:
“What do I spend today?”
It is:
“What do I want to spend money on in the life I am trying to create?”
Some people will discover that they need more than they thought. Their current spending may not reflect the holidays, experiences or generosity they hope to enjoy later.
Others will discover that they need less because part of their existing budget consists of commitments that no longer earn their place.
Both discoveries are useful.
A financial plan built around the wrong spending target can be mathematically precise and still point you towards the wrong destination.
You could spend years trying to close a shortfall that does not really exist. You could delay retirement to preserve a lifestyle partly made up of things you barely notice.
Before deciding that you need a bigger pension, ask whether you first need a better retirement budget.
Open your bank statement and look at every recurring payment.
Choose one you no longer value.
Work out what it costs each year. Then consider how much additional capital might be needed to support it throughout retirement.
Finally, ask yourself:
How much longer am I willing to work to keep paying for this?
Sometimes the most expensive costs are the ones we no longer notice.
Enjoyed this article?
Tomorrow's Notes is one thoughtful email every Friday about money, time and living well.
Join free: